Republican · Incumbent · U.S. Senate (ME) · 2026
Chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee whose institutional seniority and influence over federal spending define her legislative power.
Before politics: Staff to U.S. Sen. William S. Cohen 1975-1987; Staff Director, Senate Oversight Subcommittee 1981-1987; Commissioner, Maine Dept. of Professional & Financial Regulation 1987-1992; New England Regional Director, U.S. SBA 1992-1993; founding executive director, Center for Family Business, Husson College 1994-1996.
Susan Collins faces a narrow path to reelection as she lags in independent polling and trails her challenger in total funds raised within a state that leans toward the opposing party.
While Susan Collins maintains a robust fundraising operation, her reliance on significant outside committee spending suggests a coalition that requires heavy external reinforcement.
The combination of unresolved ethics allegations and the loss of the seat in 2026 creates a high vulnerability that threatens to derail her candidacy.
The legislative record of Susan Collins increasingly struggles to reconcile her traditional institutional focus with a shifting electorate concerned by her past voting decisions.
Opposes Trump's tariffs on Canada; calls them a mistake.
pro-labor; opposes tariffs and corporate influence on economy
Who this moves: Maine voters concerned about economic impact of trade conflicts.
1 of 6
| Issue | Susan Collins | Troy Jackson | Who this moves |
|---|---|---|---|
| Economy and taxes | Opposes Opposes Trump's tariffs on Canada; calls them a mistake. | Supports pro-labor; opposes tariffs and corporate influence on economy | Maine voters concerned about economic impact of trade conflicts. |
| Healthcare | Opposes Opposes Medicare for All; voted against OBBBA Medicaid cuts. | Supports supports Medicare for All and prescription drug price negotiation | Workers at Bath Iron Works concerned about private insurance. |
| Abortion and social issues | Supports Supports abortion rights; defends 2018 Kavanaugh confirmation vote. | Supports supports federal abortion rights; shifted from past opposition | Maine women voters alienated by her 2018 Kavanaugh vote. |
| Democracy and elections | No record Incumbent defeated in 2026; attributes loss to Trump's unpopularity. | Supports populist challenger; opposes voter ID and Senate leadership | Voters in municipalities who shifted from Collins in 2020 to Jackson. |
| Immigration and border | Supports Supports ICE reform; opposes abolition; secured body-cam funding. | Opposes advocates for abolishing ICE and reallocating its funding | Voters divided on the role and necessity of ICE. |
| Foreign policy and defense | Mixed Opposed Hegseth nomination; voted against Trump on Iran. | Opposes opposes unconditional military funding for Israel; labels Gaza genocide | Voters focused on military involvement and party independence. |
| Credibility axis | Susan Collins | Troy Jackson |
|---|---|---|
Insider knowledge | Five-term U.S. Senator; former Chair of Senate Appropriations Committee. | Former Maine Senate president and state legislator. |
Message discipline | Multiple reversals reported by press, including on H.R. 1 and Hegseth. | Multiple reversals on campaign finance and abortion drew press coverage. |
Moral legitimacy | Endorsed by party organization and former Democratic Senator Joe Manchin. | Endorsed by Democratic Party and national figures like Obama. |
Scandal resilience | Multiple allegations of pay-to-play and Stock Act violations reported. | Multiple reports of physical altercations and past misconduct allegations. |
Pressure absorption | Lost 2026 general election to challenger Troy Jackson. | Lost 2026 gubernatorial primary and 2023 local board election. |
Five-term U.S. Senator; former Chair of Senate Appropriations Committee.
Former Maine Senate president and state legislator.
1 of 5
Endorsements and money spent against
Senator Susan Collins leverages her influential leadership role on the Senate Appropriations Committee to maintain her profile in Maine. She appeals to voters prioritizing party independence and military defense, though she faces persistent alienation from segments of the female electorate. Her ability to defend this seat depends on whether institutional longevity can offset shifting voter sentiments and a significant campaign fundraising gap.